A well-trained dog is a happy dog, and a happy dog makes for an even more satisfied dog owner. For most puppy parents, the most lucrative way of training your animal is by rewarding their positive behaviors with tasty treats. It is a natural, tried-and-true method. In addition to helping with training, treats can act as the perfect vehicle for various medications and treatments that otherwise may seem extremely unappetizing to your pet.
Comparison Table
Product Name | Price |
|---|---|
Old Mother Hubbard  image source: Amazon | |
Zuke's  image source: Amazon | |
Blue Buffalo  image source: Amazon | |
NUTRO  image source: Amazon |
With the arrival of special "medicinal" treats – snacks designed explicitly for proper bone, joint, urinary, digestive, and dental health – dog owners can rejoice in knowing that their pup's favorite treats are fulfilling a dietary need, while still being incredibly delicious.
But there are hundreds of brands of dog treats from which to choose. Since 2011, US consumers have seen an increase of more than 70% in terms of available brands. This increase means that there are over 600 different brands of dog treats on the market today. With so much saturation, it takes quite a lot for a brand to stand out from the others.
Old Mother Hubbard Dog Treats tend to earn high ratings on Amazon, in addition to being featured in several "Best Treats" lists and blogs. So, the question becomes, are they any good? Let's find out!
What Are Old Mother Hubbard Dog Treats?
image source: pexels
Old Mother Hubbard Dog Treats are a line of – mostly – all-natural dog treats. Founded in 1926, the Old Mother Hubbard Bakery has been creating delicious dog treats for nearly a century. However, in the 1990s their focus drifted to producing the finest, most nutritious dog treats and foods. In 2009, the bakery joined the WellPet company.
They offer seven significant categories of treats from which to choose. The Classic treats are crunchy, bone-shaped treats that come in ten flavors: Original, P-Nuttier, Extra Tasty, Chicken Pot Pie, Bac’N’Cheese, Liv’R’Crunch, Just Vegg’N, Char-Tar, Puppy, and Chick’N’Apple.
The Mother’s Solutions line offer four kinds of medicinal treats. They include Fresh Breath, Hip & Joint, Fresh Breath, and Tartar Control. The Grain-Free category features three flavors: All The Fixins, P-Nuttier N’ Nanners, and Pick Of The Patch. The mini treats which are perfect for training are known as Bitz, and they come in several flavors, from chicken and liver to veggies.
image source: Amazon
Old Mother Hubbard even offers seasonal treats! For the winter season, they offer the Jingle Jangle, a bag filled with peanut butter dog treats in the shape of Christmas trees. During October, they sell Creepy Crunchers, which are mostly the same recipe as the Jingle Jangle treats but in the form of a bat. And in February, Old Mother Hubbard offers you and your pup Bits of Love, which are P-Nuttier treats in the shape of hearts.
The Big Ol’ Bone line offers two choices in nutritious and chewable bone-shaped treats. You can choose from P-Nuttier and Bac’N’Cheese.
The Soft & Tasty category of treats does contain a preservative, sorbic acid, but it is the only chemical additive in any of the Old Mother Hubbard brand treats, and they are very vocal about its addition and why they felt they needed to add it.
Sorbic acid is essential in keeping the soft treats from spoiling. The soft treats are available in three flavors. There’s Beef & Sweet Potato, Chicken & Veggies, and Peanut Butter & Bacon.
Features And Specifications
Total Varieties: 26
Categories of Treats: 7
All-Natural Ingredients: Yes – 84% of all products are all-natural
Average Price Per Bag: $8.98
Average Amount Per Bag (oz): 26oz
Health and Wellness Treats: Yes
Pricing
The price of Old Mother Hubbard Dog Treats depends on the type, and quantity of treats you're looking to purchase. The average cost for a 20oz bag of treats is $6.99, and the sizeable 20lb box of treats can run up to $65.99. This size disparity means that the average price for these treats is about $0.28 per oz.
Old Mother Hubbard Dog Treats are available online and in-store at most major pet stores. You can find them online at Amazon, Chewy.com, and PetFlow. You can also pick them up in person from Petco, PetSmart, Target, and Walmart.
How It Compares
We compared Old Mother Hubbard Dog Treats with three of the highest-rated and most popular leading brands to find out if they were the best.
Old Mother Hubbard
Price
The average price per 20oz bag of Mother Hubbard Dog Treats is $$$. When you include all treats on the product line, the average cost per oz for these treats is $.
All-Natural Ingredients
Yes. Old Mother Hubbard uses natural ingredients including: apples, barley flour, brown rice, cane molasses, canola oil, carrots, charcoal, chicken, cranberry seed, eggs, fennel, fish oil, flaxseed, herring, lamb, oatmeal, olive oil, peas, potatoes, rosemary extract, salmon, spinach, squash, sunflower oil, sweet potatoes, tomatoes, turkey, turmeric, venison, and wheat.
Their soft treats contain the only artificial ingredients: sorbic acid.
Availability
Because Old Mother Hubbard Dog Treats are widely available both online and at major pet stores, they earn 4/5 stars.
Number of Varieties
With 26 varieties of Old Mother Hubbard treats to choose from, from 7 broad categories. This brand earns an average rating in variations.
3/5 stars.
Flavor
With so many flavors to choose from, and with many reviewers exclaiming how much their dogs love these treats, Old Mother Hubbard earns a flavor rating of 4/5.
image source: pexels
Zuke’s
image source: Amazon
Price
The average price for a 12oz bag of Zuke's Crunchy Naturals is about $$$, but if you include their entire product line, the average cost per oz of treat is $$. This price is far higher than Old Mother Hubbard's.
All-Natural Ingredients
Yes. Zuke's Dog Treats contain many whole and natural ingredients, but they also contain many added vitamins, including ascorbic acid, beta-carotene, calcium lactate, chondroitin sulfate, citric acid, glucono delta-lactone, phosphoric acid, sorbic acid, vegetable glycerin and "mixed tocopherols."
Despite the added vitamins and preservatives, Zuke’s treats contain no wheat, soy, corn, or by-products. This absence is a hugely attractive feature for pet owners.
Availability
Though Zuke's Dog Treats are available online at Amazon, PetFlow, Chewy.com, Petco and PetSmart, they are notoriously difficult to find in-store. Also, the variety of treats available for purchase ranges from location to location, often with very few options from the Zuke's line.
Because of this, Zuke's Dog Treats only earn 3/5 stars for availability.
Number of Varieties
With over 30 different specific kinds of treats to choose from and eight categories to pick from, Zuke's offers an outstanding amount of variety.
For this reason, they earn 4/5 stars.
Flavor
Treats range in flavor from duck and chicken to peanut butter and berries, ensuring that there is a flavor for every dog’s palate. Reviewers note that their dogs love eating these treats.
Therefore, Zuke's Dog Treats earns 4/5 stars for flavor.
image source: pexels
Blue Buffalo
image source: Amazon
Price
The average price for an 8oz bag of Blue Buffalo dog treats is $$$. When you include the costs of all the dog treats offered by Blue Buffalo, the average price per oz is $$. Though more expensive than Old Mother Hubbard treats, Blue Buffalo treats are still less costly than Zuke's.
All-Natural Ingredients
Yes. Much like Zuke's, Blue Buffalo makes their snacks with natural, whole ingredients while also adding essential vitamins and minerals. Free from, corn, wheat, soy, and animal by-products, Blue Buffalo dry foods and treats provide a substantial amount of protein without any shady sources. They are also free from preservatives, unlike most brands.
Availability
Blue Buffalo products are available online on Amazon, Chewy.com, Petco, and PetSmart. They are also widely available in-store at most pet stores and department stores such as Walmart and Target.
Because they are one of the most popular brands, and one of the easiest to find, they earn 5/5 stars for availability.
Number of Varieties
Blue Buffalo currently offers 50 different kinds of dog treats, all organized under a broad 14 categories.
It is the brand that offers the most variety, and because of this, they earn 5/5 stars.
Flavor
Pet owners rave about how much their dogs love Blue Buffalo treats, and it is one of the highest-rated brands on the market that satisfies the need for excellent canine nutrition, health, and happiness. 5/5 stars.
image source: pexels
NUTRO
image source: Amazon
Price
The average price for a 10oz bag of NUTRO Dog Treats is $$, and the average price per oz among all NUTRO treats is $, making it one of the least expensive options included in this list.
All-Natural Ingredients
Yes. NUTRO is dedicated to using only non-GMO ingredients in their products. They offer treats that are free from wheat, corn, soy, and artificial flavors and preservatives. Unfortunately, they do use many natural preservatives in nearly all their treats, as well as gelatin. Their treats are not as wholesome as Blue Buffalo or Old Mother Hubbard treats, but they are made with natural ingredients.
Availability
Numerous types of NUTRO Dog Treats are available online at Amazon, Chewy.com, PetFlow, Petco and PetSmart.
They are also available in-store, though your options are far more limited. 4/5 stars.
Number of Varieties
NUTRO offers 25 different kinds of dog treats, which is nearly on par with Old Mother Hubbard treats. These treats are separated into eight categories.
However, because they offer the least amount of options – out of the brands included in this comparison – they earn an average 3/5 stars.
Flavor
Pet owners praise NUTRO treats for their pleasant smell, use in training, and how much their dogs love eating them!
NUTRO treats are rated highly in consumer reviews, and with several flavors to choose from, NUTRO earns 4/5 stars for taste.
Pros And Cons
Every product has positive and negative attributes, no matter how highly-rated and well-reviewed it is. Let’s explore the Pros and Cons of Old Mother Hubbard Dog Treats.
Pros
Cons
Conclusion
There are a lot of extraordinary things to be said for Old Mother Hubbard Dog Treats. They're a wholesome option that will alleviate any guilt or worry about your dog's nutrition. However, the treats could be healthier, and the company could certainly expand their product line to appeal to the needs and desires of consumers and their pets.
The Old Mother Hubbard is still growing and is not yet the best brand available. Therefore, Old Mother Hubbard Dog Treats earn 4/5 stars.
Leave a Reply